MATHEWS, SARAH* AND MICHAEL J. DONOGHUE. Harvard University Herbaria, Cambridge, MA 02138. - Duplicate gene rooting and difficult rooting problems in plant phylogeny.
Duplicate gene rooting may be especially useful in cases where there
is no outgroup available (e.g., the entire tree of life), or in cases
where the branch connecting an outgroup and ingroup is very long. In
the latter case, one advantage lies in the potential of reducing long
branch effects. If a gene were to have duplicated along a long branch
leading to an ingroup, the resulting forms of the gene would share a
more recent common ancestor than either one would with the single gene
present in outgroup taxa, effectively bisecting the long branch. Two
approaches to duplicate gene rooting have been elucidated. Under the
"reciprocal outgroups" interpretation of the approach, trees
from one gene copy are rooted with a single gene or few copies of the
other form. Congruence of the separate gene trees is evaluated after
separate analyses and provides the criterion for choosing a rooted
species tree; if the separate gene trees conflict regarding the root,
a decision is not possible. Under the "minimum events"
interpretation of the approach, simultaneous analysis of both genes
results in an unrooted gene network. Costs of fitting the two-gene
network into a set of possible species trees provide the criteria for
choosing the best rooted species tree. We discuss the merits of the
two approaches, as well as the effects of including outgroups in
duplicate gene analyses. Finally, we discuss the potential of the
approach to resolve difficult rooting problems in plant phylogeny, and
we review the examples of duplicate gene rooting in plant phylogenetic
studies to date, including examples using duplicate genes encoding
phosphoglucose isomerases, alcohol dehydrogenases, and phytochromes.
Key words: Duplicate genes, rooting