ALVERSON, WILLIAM S.*, BARBARA A. WHITLOCK, RETO NYFFELER, AND DAVID A. BAUM. Harvard University Herbaria, Cambridge, MA 02138. - Phylogeny of core Malvales: evidence from ndhF sequence data.
The monophyly of the group comprising the core malvalean families -
Bombacaceae, Malvaceae, Sterculiaceae, and Tiliaceae - was recently
confirmed by molecular studies employing rbcL sequence data.
The internal structure of this clade is poorly understood, however,
limiting our understanding of the evolution of this large group and
thwarting any reliable taxonomic classification. In this study, we
examined sequences of the chloroplast ndhF gene (aligned length
2252 bp) from 70 exemplars representing 34 of the 40 putative tribes
or subfamilies of core malvalean families. The monophyly of one
family, the Malvaceae, was strongly supported but the other three
families, as traditionally circumscribed, were non-monophyletic. The
phylogenetic trees resulting from these analyses indicate the
following four major clades: 1) A clade consisting of the Malvaceae
plus all traditional Bombacaceae (except some members of tribe
Durioneae), plus Fremontodendron and Chiranthodendron, which are
usually treated as Sterculiaceae; 2) a strong clade supported by a
unique 21 bp deletion and consisting of the aforemention plus some
representatives of Sterculiaceae and Tiliaceae, plus Durio and
Neesia (both Durioneae); 3) a clade containing genera
traditionally assigned to tribes Byttnerieae, Hermannieae, and
Lasiopetaleae of Sterculiaceae; and 4) a clade with genera
traditionally assigned to several tribes of Tiliaceae. The most
striking departures from traditional classifications are that Durio
and relatives appear to be more closely related to Helicteres
and Reevesia ("Sterculiaceae") than to
"Bombacaceae"; that several genera traditionally considered
as Bombacaceae (Camptostemon, Matisia, and Quararibea)
or Sterculiaceae (Chiranthodendron and Fremontodendron)
appear as sister lineages to the core Malvaceae clade; and that
Sterculiaceae and Tiliaceae, as traditionally circumscribed,
represent polyphyletic groups that cannot sensibly be maintained for
purposes of classification. We also discuss supporting morphological
characters and recommendations for provisional nomenclature for core
Malvales.
Key words: Malvales, ndhF, phylogeny