LUPIA, RICHARD. Department of Geology, The Field Museum, Roosevelt Road at Lake Shore Drive, Chicago, IL 60605. - Discerning patchy vegetation using replicate samples: a Cretaceous example.
A single sample from living vegetation provides a measure of the
diversity and abundance of plant species in the sample area at the
time of sampling. Due to spatial and temporal averaging, a single
paleobotanical sample provides only an estimate of the diversity and
abundance of species that lived within the source area during the
deposition of sediments. However, to estimate the patchiness of the
vegetation across both modern and ancient landscapes, multiple samples
must be used to identify variation in the distribution of species.
Here I present a method to identify whether observed variation among
paleobotanical samples is an artifact of random sampling or whether
that variation could represent patchy vegetation or different
taphonomic regimes. Three replicates were collected for each of four
samples across a mudstone lens preserving a floodplain pond at the
Allon locality (Crawford Co., GA). The lens is about 16m across with
a maximum thickness of 0.8m. Samples were processed by sieving to
recover mesofossils (charcoalified and lignified plant debris) and all
identifiable specimens (approximately 11,000) were assigned to one of
46 morphotypes and counted. Samples drawn from the same original
source population should differ only due to the effects of random
sampling. The method compares variation within a sample (measured as
the distribution of dissimilarities between replicates) to variation
among samples after correcting for differences in sample size. If
samples are more dissimilar to each other than expected from
dissimilarity among replicates, then the samples reflect the patchy
distribution of fossils across the outcrop. The differences among
samples are therefore due to patchiness in the original vegetation or
to a non-random bias in the preservation of fossils. The possibility
of preservation biases can be addressed using additional (e.g.,
sedimentological) evidence.
Key words: heterogeneity, methods, paleobotany, paleoecology, patchiness, sampling