DERETSKY, ZINA. Division of Paleobotany, Peabody Museum, Yale University, PO Box 208118, New Haven CT 06520. - A fifty million year record of insect damage in the leaves of Platanaceae.
Damage caused by insects is common in fossil leaves. This study
examined the question of whether the incidence of insect leaf damage
increased during an approximately 50 million year span of angiosperm
history, both overall and within a single clade, the Platanaceae.
Platanaceae were chosen as the sample lineage because their leaves are
readily identifiable and the group has a well documented first
appearance approximately 5 to 10 Myr prior to the Cenomanian. A
series of five fossil floras were examined: the Dakota Flora of Kansas
(~98 Ma; Cenomanian), the Eagle Flora of northwestern Wyoming (~81 Ma;
Campanian), the Hell Creek Flora of southwest North Dakota (~65-67 Ma;
Maastrichtian), the Fort Union Flora of east central Montana (~63 Ma;
Torrejonian) and the Kishenehn Flora from western Montana (~50 Ma;
Eocene). Eight different categories of insect leaf damage were
identified and tracked in these floras. Overall incidence of
angiosperm leaf damage increases sharply from a mean value of 12.3
occurrences per 50 leaves (12.3/50) in the Dakota Flora to values
above 33/50 in the four later floras. Incidence of all categories of
leaf damage to the Platanaceae in the Dakota Flora is considerably
less (8.9/50) than in the non-Platanaceae (25.6/50). Thereafter, the
difference in the leaf damage index for the Platanaceae does not
differ significantly from the damage index for other angiosperms, with
the possible exception of the Hell Creek Flora where the platanaceous
damage index is 31.6/50 as opposed to 37.3/50 for non-Platanaceae.
However, throughout the interval from the Cenomanian to the Eocene,
the Platanaceae remained consistently less susceptible to margin
feeding than the non-platanaceous angiosperms. Between the Cenomanian
and the Campanian two new types of leaf damage appear: window feeding
and skeletonization. At first, these damage types occur less
frequently in Platanaceae but this differential is erased by the
Maastrichtian. Among leaf mines, an Ectoedemia-like
(Nepticulidae) mine first appears in the Maastrichtian Hell Creek
Flora, and mines of Paraclemensia (Incurvariidae) appear
between the Hell Creek Flora and the Fort Union Formation.
Key words: Eocene, insect leaf damage, Late Cretaceous, Paleocene, Platanaceae