| Needs of Marginalized
Students |
Possible Responses by Teachers: |
|
Feeling Welcome:
- They often feel ignored, or that their cultural heritage is
not valued.
- They get subtle messages from the teacher, often in the form
of humor, that their social group is demeaned.
- They would like to have some labels for their social group used,
rather than others.
- They hear language and comments from other students in class
that demean them or their culture.
|
- Be careful about using humor that labels groups or is disparaging
towards categories of people.
- At the start of a course, acknowledge the presence of diverse
students and welcome their input.
- Be considerate in addressing social groups as they wish to be
addressed.
- Monitor and address comments by students in the class that may
demean other people.
Curricular Responses:
- Incorporate and make visible the contributions to this subject
by individuals from different backgrounds.
- Incorporate questions and issues important to different social
and cultural groups of people.
|
|
Being Treated as an Individual
- Teachers have and use stereotypes, e.g., athletic African-Americans,
smart and studious Asian-Americans.
- Students often do not feel qualified to speak for "their
cultural group."
- Students from marginal groups have difficulty finding a mentor.
|
- Be pro-active in seeking personal contact with students, especially
those who may otherwise feel separated or excluded.
- Try to serve as a mentor, when possible, to people "different
from yourself."
|
|
Being Able to Participate Fully
- Classrooms often reflect the values of the dominant social culture,
and do not leave room for other cultural values.
- Students have learning styles and/or social interaction styles
that are different from those of the instructor.
|
- Become more aware of your own cultural values.
- Try to see your own culture and your own preferred way of learning,
as one in a field of many cultures and different ways of learning,
each with its own values and limitations.
|
|
Being Treated Fairly
- Teachers sometimes feel that equal treatment means the same
treatment, thereby ignoring individual differences.
- Students sometimes misunderstand the meaning of expectations
and don't see the reasons for these expectations, because of their
social background.
|
- Use varied teaching approaches.
- When possible, use "redundant" teaching, e.g., talk
about a topic (straight analysis or narrative), use visual images
(visual), and discussion (social dialogue).
- If it seems necessary, meet individually with students to explain
the expectations of the class and the reasons for these.
- Balance (a) the need for order and routine with (b) the need
for variety and richness of different perspectives.
|
References:
1. "Taking Student Diversity into Account", by
Nancy Chism, Chapter 22 in Teaching Tips by Wilbert J. McKeachie
and Others. Lexington, Mass.: Heath, 1994. Offers an excellent brief summary
of the needs of diverse students, what teachers sometimes do that create
or exacerbate these problems, and some suggestions for how to respond
more effectively to the needs of diverse students.
2. Tools for Teaching by Barbara Gross Davis. San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1993. Has four chapters on this topic, each with
thoughtful insights and suggestions: Chap. 4: "Academic Accommodations
for Students with Disabilities," Chap. 5: "Diversity and Complexity
in the Classroom: Considerations of Race, Ethnicity, and Gender,"
Chap. 6: "Reentry Students," Chap. 7: "Teaching Academically
Diverse Students."
3. Teaching for Diversity edited by Laura L.B. Border and Nancy
Van Note Chism. New Directions for Teaching and Learning series,
No. 49. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1992. Contains several short essays
on how individuals and institutions are responding to the need to provide
better quality learning experiences for diverse students.
4. Handbook of College Teaching edited by Keith W.
Prichard and R. McLaren Sawyer. Westport, Conn.:Greenwood Press, 1994.
Has two chapters on this topic: Chap. 29: "Students at Risk for Academic
Failure: Learning to Learn Classes," Chap. 30: "Instructional
Considerations for College Students with Disabilities."
5. Promoting Diversity in College Classrooms: Innovate Response
for the Curriculum, Faculty and Institutions edited by Maurianne Adams.
New Directions for Teaching and Learning series, No. 52. San Francisco:
Jossey-Bass, 1992.
|